Helmets aren't enough, urban cyclists should don armour, says study

Carlton Reid
Helmets aren't enough, urban cyclists should don armour, says study

Canadian trauma surgeons have compared injuries between 'street cyclists' and mountain bikers and say both groups should consider wearing chest protection. This is in addition to cycle helmets.

"Helmet and thoracic protection should be advocated as injury prevention measures," concludes the study, carried out by surgeons at the Foothills Medical Centre in Calgary, Canada.

A University of Calgary press release issued earlier today said the research study, published in the Canadian Journal of Surgery, looks at incidence, risk factors and injury patterns over a 14-year period among 258 severely injured cyclists in southern Alberta, Canada.

The trauma surgeon's study doesn't list any other transport modes that may also need protective wear, just cycling. (And, yes, the press release really does use a library photograph of helmet-wearing cyclists from the late 1980s or early 1990s).

“Trauma to the head is still the number one injury in both cycling groups, which underscores the importance of wearing a good-quality, properly-fitted helmet,” said Dr. Chad Ball, the senior author of the research paper.

Article continues below

Advertisement

“At the same time, almost half of the injuries we noted were either to the chest or abdomen, suggesting that greater physical protection in those areas could also help reduce or prevent serious injury.”

The release adds: "Many specialized bike shops now carry a variety of protective vests, often referred to as body armour, which provide a mix of padding and hard-shell coverage."

Remember, the surgeons are recommending body armour for riding to work or popping to the shops, as well as mountain biking.

The study reports that, with 370 km of bicycling lanes and pathways, Calgary has the "largest network of bike paths per 100 000 population in Canada."

The trauma surgeons do not stress that the public health benefits of using this dense network of bike paths will far outweigh the risks of crashes. Nor do the surgeons advocate measures to remove risk, such as limiting car speeds, or building more bike paths, despite the study saying "street cyclists were commonly injured after being hit by a motor vehicle." (The same one each time?)

A study from March this year, and also from the University of Calgary, showed that collisions with motor vehicles pose the greatest threat to cyclists. Helmets and body armour are not designed to protect cyclists who hit, or are hit by, cars and HGVs.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tags: helmets , Body Armour , michelin man , calgary , are you mad? , hey how about for drivers and pedestrians and skaters , too?

Follow us on

  • RSS