Are helmet safeguards a step too far?

Jersey-based Arthur Lamy gives his perspective on the island’s landmark helmet legislation that passed last month, and only narrowly avoided making helmets compulsory for adults...
Author:
Publish date:
95_mypictr_185x185.jpg

Last month, the States of Jersey – the island’s parliament – voted to make it compulsory for every cyclist under the age of 18 to wear a helmet. The motion had been tabled by deputy Andrew Green MBE, founder of the Jersey branch of the brain injury charity Headway, and current national chairman. Deputy Green has campaigned for greater awareness since his son, Christopher, suffered brain injuries as a child of nine, in a cycling accident 21 years ago.

Deputy Green’s proposal was underpinned by a body of evidence, taken from various countries around the world that have brought in helmet laws, and the opinions of health professionals who deal with this type of trauma on a daily basis. But it would be fair to say that the House was moved by their personal feelings as much as any evidence.

Several members of the House brought forward the point that ultimately it was the parent’s responsibility to ensure that their offspring were protected rather than society. Others felt that life was full of possible dangers, and it was more a question of how these risks were addressed.

The principle opponent to the introduction of the new law was keen cyclist and deputy Daniel Wimberley. Before becoming a politician, he owned a cycle hire business and was chairman of the Jersey Cycling Group. His main point was that there wasn’t enough conclusive evidence to back up deputy Green’s argument and that if a law came in, it would effectively discourage people from cycling, with the loss of the health and environmental benefits that went with it.

EMOTIONS RULED MOTION
After an emotive two-day debate, the motion was passed in favour of a compulsory helmet law for under 18-year-olds by 33 votes to 16. A motion proposing that the law be extended to adults as well was very narrowly defeated by one vote.

Opinion among local cycle retailers was unified. Most dealers felt they would see a small increase in the sales of children’s and youths’ helmets, especially in the run-up to the law being implemented, which is still 18 months away. Going on past sales, dealers agreed that most children already had helmets, usually because their parents felt it was wise, or because their school or one of the groups that they belonged to insisted on it.

What did concern them was how the law would be implemented – could Jersey's police force spare the time to pursue such minor offences? Who would be held responsible: the rider or their parents? It’s often the case that kids leave home with a helmet on their head only for it to be hung on their handlebars the moment that they are out of sight.

Cycle dealers all agreed that if the law had been applied to every cyclist, it would have been an unnecessary burden that would deter casual riders from using their bikes. Who would bother with a quick dash to the shops if you’d suddenly become an outlaw by forgetting to put your helmet on?

I’ve always been keen to get as many people cycling as possible, and I feel that a law that forces everyone to wear a helmet would be detrimental. After all, cycling is sustainable, cheap, healthy and good for the environment, and people should be encouraged to enjoy these benefits.

However, in this instance I don’t think that the numbers of children who cycle at present will be unduly affected, simply because so many of them do already wear helmets. Hopefully, by the time they are old enough to choose for themselves they can make an informed judgement about whether to continue wearing one without the need for legislation to force them one way or the other.

Finally, maybe I’m old-fashioned, but shouldn’t it fall to the parents to safeguard their children, rather than the Government?

Arthur Lamy ran St. Helier-set bike shop Boudins for almost 30 years and now
works as a Blue Badge accredited freelance tourist guide and freelance writer.
He specialises in cycling and walking tours.
www.cycleinjersey.com

Featured Jobs

Iride

Customer Services Support

i-ride.co.uk I Burgess Hill, Sussex I Competitive Salary Plus Commission I Date Published Tuesday 20th November 2018

frog bikes promo

R&D Manager

Frog Bikes I Ascot I Salary: £22k-£26k (depending on qualification and experience) I Date Published Tuesday 6th November 2018