New study pours cold water on claims that compulsory hi-vis provides safety benefits

Italy has a law forcing cyclists to wear hi-vis clothing at night, but a new study has found that this law has had little to no impact on the numbers of road crashes in which cyclists were killed or injured.

The study has been published in the latest Journal of Transport & Health. It was authored by Gabriele Prati of the University of Bologna's psychology department. She found that "bicycling visibility-aids law had no influence on bicycle crash[es]."

Prati's study was based on crashes recorded between 2001 and 2015 by the Italian National Institute of Statistics. After the numbers were crunched she found that the "implementation of legislation imposing high-visibility clothing for cyclists did not influence the number of bicycles involved in road crashes."

She added: "The introduction of the legislation did not produce immediate effects, nor did it have any effects over time."

The Italian wear-reflectives-at-night-law is poorly enforced and therefore largely ignored. The study did not evaluate the clothing used by those involved in crashes.

Last month UK roads minister Jesse Norman unveiled details on a Cycling and Walking Investment Strategy Safety Review that earlier he had promised would "not going to be based on any knee jerk reaction; it will be based on solid evidence." 

And in an interview in The Guardian Norman said that "there will be some people who feel very strongly that there should be hi-vis [for cyclists], and there will be plenty of people who think very strongly the other way."

Featured Jobs

cls logo_jpg 600x348

Bike Mechanic

Club La Santa I Lanzarote, Canary Islands I Competitive Salary & Benefits I Date Published Monday 7th January 2019

LTR coral logo 620x349

Local Project Manager (x3 roles)

Love to Ride I North East Lincolnshire, Slough, Southampton I Salary: £32,500 equivalent (PT, temporary) I Date Published Monday 7th January 2019

Logo stacked

Head of Marketing

Brompton I West London I Salary Competitive I Date Published Wednesday 9th January 2019

BE2016_googlelogo

Senior Sales Executive

BikeExchange I UK Nationwide I Salary TBC Depending on level of experience I Date published Wednesday 16th January 2019